Inhaltsverzeichnis
Probekapitel
The second section focuses on a critical analysis of compatibilism. In this context, Angus Menuge also discusses the question of concrete evidence for a free will. Friedrich Toepel examines the relevance of alternative models, and Mateusz Klinowski argues that many of the relevant questions can already be answered by applying logical principles. In both sections, John W. Montgomery also provides rare insights into the theological background of the topic.
Mehr zum Thema

Toepel, Friedrich (Hrsg.)
Free Will in Criminal Law and Procedure
Proceedings of the 23rd and 24th IVR World Congress Kraków 2007 and Beijing 2009
Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie – Beihefte (ARSP-B)
Band 120
ISBN 978-3-515-09320-0
| EUR | 26,00 |
| EUR(A) | 26,80 |
| sFr* | 44,20 |
| Preise jeweils inklusive MwSt. | |
* Unverbindliche Preisempfehlung für sFr
Abstract
This supplement to the Archives for Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy (ARSP) covers all of the fundamental aspects of the free will problem, concentrating on questions of criminal and procedural law. In the first section the concept of free will is analyzed and the deterministic approach of Ronald J. Allen is discussed as laid out in his essay "Miranda’s Hollow Core" in the Northwestern Law Review. The section is concluded by Professor Allen’s reply to his critics. Professor Allen’s determinism stands in contrast to the libertarianism of David Hodgson and Friedrich Toepel. The essays of Allan McCay and Juan Pablo Mañalich concentrate on compatibilistic theories.The second section focuses on a critical analysis of compatibilism. In this context, Angus Menuge also discusses the question of concrete evidence for a free will. Friedrich Toepel examines the relevance of alternative models, and Mateusz Klinowski argues that many of the relevant questions can already be answered by applying logical principles. In both sections, John W. Montgomery also provides rare insights into the theological background of the topic.
1st Edition 2010.
122 p.
soft cover
Franz Steiner Verlag
Über den Autor
Autoren
Friedrich Toepel
Friedrich Toepel received his PhD in law at Constance University in 1990 with his book on ‘Causation and Imputation Concerning Negligent Crimes’. He received his "Habilitation" (professorial thesis and state doctorate) at the faculty of law of Bonn University in 1999 with his study on ‘Basic Structures of Expert Evidence in Criminal Procedure’. Since then he has given lectures at the faculties of law in Bonn and Dresden. In 2005–2006 he was a Fulbright scholar at Northwestern University School of Law.
His main areas of research are the theoretical foundations of criminal and procedural law. His publications, also his dissertation and his habilitation study, are characterised by the effort to clarify legal problems with the means of analytic philosophy.
His main areas of research are the theoretical foundations of criminal and procedural law. His publications, also his dissertation and his habilitation study, are characterised by the effort to clarify legal problems with the means of analytic philosophy.
- On the Philosophy of Precedent (Band 133)
- Human Rights, Language and Law (Band 131)
- Global Harmony and the Rule of Law (Band 130)
- Recht und Verantwortung / Droit et responsabilité (Band 129)
- Gleichheit und Universalität (Band 128)
- Interdisciplinary Research in Jurisprudence and Constitutionalism (Band 127)
- Zur Kompetenz der Rechtsphilosophie in Rechtsfragen (Band 126)
- Konflikte im Recht – Recht der Konflikte (Band 125)
- Legal Reasoning: The Methods of Balancing (Band 124)
- Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie
Bibliographie und Dokumentation (1907–2009) (Band 123) - Alternative Methods in the Education of Philosophy of Law and the Importance of Legal Philosophy in the Legal Education (Band 122)
- Recht und Globalisierung / Droit et Mondialisation (Band 121)
- Free Will in Criminal Law and Procedure (Band 120)
- On the Nature of Legal Principles (Band 119)
- Religion and State – From separation to cooperation? (Band 118)
- Rechtswissenschaft und Hermeneutik (Band 117)
- Rechtsphilosophie im 20. Jahrhundert –
100 Jahre Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie (Band 116) - Rechtswissenschaft als Kulturwissenschaft (Band 115)
- Normativität und Rechtskritik (Band 114)
- Kulturelle Identität als Grund und Grenze des Rechts (Band 113)
- Hundert Jahre Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie (1907–2007) (Band 112)
- Gehirnforschung und rechtliche Verantwortung (Band 111)
- Logic, Argumentation and Interpretation / Lógica, Argumentación e Interpretación (Band 110)
- Globalization, Law and Economy / Globalizaciòn, Derecho y Economía (Band 109)
- Human Rights and Ethics / Derechos humanos y Ètica (Band 108)
- Political Philosophy
Filosofía política (Band 107) - Legal Theory
Teoría del derecho (Band 106) - Staats- und Verfassungstheorie im Spannungsfeld der Disziplinen (Band 105)
- Juristische Grundlagenforschung (Band 104)
- Objektivität und Flexibilität im Recht (Band 103)
- Epistemology and Ontology (Band 102)
- Menschenwürde als Rechtsbegriff (Band 101)
- Verantwortetes Recht (Band 100)
- Der Juristische Streit (Band 99)
- Law, Morality, and Legal Positivism (Band 98)
- Proceedings of the 21st IVR World Congress (Band 97)
- Universal Minority Rights? (Band 96)
- Proceedings of the 21st IVR World Congress (Band 95)
- Das Recht im Spannungsfeld utilitaristischer und deontologischer Ethik (Band 94)
- Recht und Politik (Band 93)
- Politische Ziele und juristische Argumentation (Band 92)
- Pluralism and Law (Band 91)
- Pluralism and Law (Band 90)
- Pluralism and Law (Band 89)
- Pluralism and Law (Band 88)
- Die Bedeutung P.J.A. Feuerbachs (1775–1833) für die Gegenwart (Band 87)
- Rechtliche und ethische Fragen der Transplantationstechnologie in einem interkulturellen Vergleich (Band 86)
- Legal Philosophy: General Aspects (Band 85)
- Grenzen als Thema der Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie (Band 84)
- Der Staat der Zukunft (Band 83)
- Legal Philosophy: General Aspects (Band 82)
- Wirtschaftsethik und Recht - Ethique de l´Économie et droit - Etica dell´Économia e diritto (Band 81)
- Applied Ethics at the Turn of the Millenium (Band 80)
- Globalisierung als Problem von Gerechtigkeit und Steuerungsfähigkeit des Rechts (Band 79)
- Human Rights, Minority Rights, Women’s Rights (Band 78)
- Nietzsche und das Recht / Nietzsche et le Droit / Nietzsche e il Diritto (Band 77)
- Kommunitarismus versus Liberalismus (Band 76)
- Verantwortung zwischen materialer und prozeduraler Zurechnung (Band 75)
- Verantwortung in Recht und Moral (Band 74)
- Personsein aus bioethischer Sicht (Band 73)
- Law in a changing world: Asian alternatives (Band 72)
- Rechtsphilosophie und Rechtsdogmatik in Zeiten des Umbruchs (Band 71)
- Challenges to Law at the End of the 20th Century (Band 70)
- Challenges to Law at the End of the 20th Century (Band 69)
- Challenges to Law at the End of the 20th Century (Band 68)
- Challenges to Law at the End of the 20th Century (Band 67)
- Ethische und strukturelle Herausforderungen des Rechts (Band 66)
- Der Universalitätsanspruch des demokratischen Rechtsstaates (Band 65)
- Time, Law, and Society (Band 64)
- Criminal Justice (Band 63)
- Herausforderungen an das Recht am Ende des 20. Jahrhunderts / Défis au Droit à la Fin du XXème Siècle (Band 62)
- Law, Justice and the State (Band 61)
- Law, Justice and the State (Band 60)
- Law, Justice and the State (Band 59)
- Law, Justice and the State (Band 58)
- Constituting Families: A Study in Governance (Band 57)
- Theorien der Gerechtigkeit (Band 56)
- Law and the Public Interest (Band 55)
- Theoretische Grundlagen der Rechtspolitik (Band 54)
- Praktische Vernunft und Rechtsanwendung (Band 53)
- Praktische Vernunft, Gesetzgebung und Rechtswissenschaft (Band 52)
- Rechtssystem und praktische Vernunft / Legal System and Practical Reason (Band 51)
- Praktische Vernunft und Theorien der Gerechtigkeit (Band 50)
- Socialism and the Law. (Band 49)
- La découverte du sens en droit (Band 48)
- Retributivism and its Critics (Band 47)
- International Law and Armed Conflict (Band 46)
- Generalisierung und Individualisierung im Rechtsdenken (Band 45)
- Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie in Deutschland heute
(Band 44) - Deutsche Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie um 1900 (Band 43)
- Law and the States in modern Times (Band 42)
- Revolution and Human Rights (Band 41)
- Konstitutionalismus versus Legalismus? (Band 40)
- Biotechnologie, Ethik und Recht im wissenschaftlichen Zeitalter / (Band 39)